If I got you right then the ‘problem’ car seems to have a lower heat output (compared to the ‘good’ one) in pre-heat and dash operated mode, which would point to a heater related issue?
Another detail you mentioned: you plugged in both cars at the same time and get different results, what happens if you switch cables between the cars?
The link below might also give a few pointers:
https://myimiev.com/forum/viewtopic.php ... %2FC%20Off.